How Should the Base Oil Be Selected When High-Temperature Bearing Grease Dries Out or Cokes?

Hits: 633 img

Drying or coking of high-temperature bearing grease does not necessarily mean that the base oil lacks temperature resistance. Base-oil evaporation and oxidation, changes in thickener structure, relubrication practices, actual bearing temperature, speed and load may all contribute to failure. Phenyl silicone oil, synthetic hydrocarbons and PFPE have different operating boundaries; selection should not be based on a single “maximum temperature” value.

Why Does High-Temperature Grease Dry Out or Form Deposits?

Grease consists of a base oil, a thickener and any necessary additives. Drying during operation may result from:

  • evaporation of the base oil or its loss from the thickener network;
  • oxidation of the base oil, causing viscosity growth and deposits;
  • structural changes in the thickener at high temperature;
  • excessive relubrication intervals or blocked grease passages;
  • local bearing temperatures above the equipment’s measurement point;
  • loads or speeds outside the grease’s application range;
  • incompatibility caused by mixing different greases.

Replacing only the base oil without checking the complete grease system may therefore leave the problem unresolved.

Which Operating Conditions Must Be Confirmed?

At minimum, confirm:

  1. bearing type, dimensions and materials;
  2. normal temperature, short-term peaks and highest local temperature;
  3. speed, load, vibration and start-stop frequency;
  4. continuous or intermittent operation;
  5. exposure to air, moisture, solvents, corrosive media or oxygen;
  6. the current base oil and thickener types;
  7. relubrication method, interval and permitted maintenance time;
  8. materials used in seals and plastic parts;
  9. whether the failure appears as evaporation, leakage, hardening, coking or wear.

A specific base oil or grease grade should not be selected when these conditions are incomplete.

Which Base-Oil Options Can Be Considered?

Phenyl Silicone Oil

Phenyl silicone oil can be evaluated as a base oil for high-temperature lubricating oils or greases. Compared with conventional dimethyl silicone oil, some phenyl-modified silicone fluids exhibit different high-temperature oxidation stability and metal-lubrication behavior.

Suitability must still be verified through viscosity, bearing load, friction and wear, thickener compatibility and evaporation-loss testing.

Synthetic Hydrocarbon Base Oils

Synthetic hydrocarbon base oils are used in many industrial bearing-lubrication systems and offer different options regarding lubricity, additive compatibility and cost.

At high temperature, oxidation, evaporation, viscosity increase and deposit formation must still be assessed. High-temperature service life cannot be predicted from room-temperature viscosity alone.

PFPE

PFPE lubricants may be evaluated for high-temperature, vacuum, clean, strongly oxidizing or chemically demanding environments. Some PFPE greases are used in high-temperature, vacuum or oxygen-rich equipment, but such performance belongs to specific formulations and test conditions.

PFPE generally involves higher material and qualification costs. An ordinary industrial bearing does not necessarily require PFPE unless its cleanliness, chemical-stability or temperature requirements justify it.

Is Phenyl Silicone Oil Suitable for Every Metal Bearing?

No. Published lubrication literature indicates that conventional PDMS has lubricity limitations in some metal-to-metal applications. Phenyl-methyl silicone fluids, fluorosilicone fluids and alkyl-modified silicone fluids may behave differently, but the tribological pair, load and speed must still be verified.

For bearings operating under heavy loads, impact or significant boundary lubrication, the base oil alone may be insufficient. Anti-wear additives, solid lubricants or other lubrication systems may also need evaluation.

Why Is the Thickener Equally Important?

The same base oil combined with different thickeners can produce very different grease performance. Evaluate:

  • high-temperature structural stability of the thickener;
  • compatibility between the base oil and thickener;
  • the difference between dropping point and actual operating temperature;
  • oil separation and evaporation loss at high temperature;
  • shear stability and relubrication behavior;
  • compatibility with the old grease.

A high dropping point does not mean that a grease can operate continuously near that temperature.

Common Selection Mistakes

Looking Only at the Maximum Temperature

Continuous temperature, short-term peak temperature and test conditions must be distinguished.

Assuming Phenyl Silicone Oil Cannot Coke

Phenyl silicone oils offer relevant thermal-stability characteristics, but contamination, overheating, unsuitable formulation and metal-catalyzed reactions may still change their performance.

Assuming PFPE Fits Every High-Temperature Bearing

PFPE must also be matched to speed, load, thickener, tribological pair and cost. It is not required for every machine.

Replacing Only the Base Oil

Grease failure may also originate from the thickener, additives, relubrication method or bearing design.

Mixing Old and New Greases Directly

Different thickener systems may soften, harden or separate when mixed. Compatibility should be confirmed before changing grease; the original lubrication system should be cleaned when necessary.

Recommended Selection Procedure

First, confirm the bearing’s actual temperature, speed, load and surrounding media. Second, determine whether the old grease failed through evaporation, oxidation, leakage or thickener breakdown. Third, compare phenyl silicone oil, synthetic hydrocarbons, PFPE and other candidate base oils. Fourth, match the thickener and any necessary anti-wear system. Finally, verify high-temperature operation, evaporation, oil separation, wear and material compatibility before confirming the solution.

As a global silicone solutions provider, IOTA Silicone Oil (Anhui) Co., Ltd. can assist in screening phenyl silicone oils and other specialty functional silicone fluids for high-temperature lubrication. If the actual load, medium or cleanliness requirements favor another material, it should also be included objectively. No grade should be specified before the operating conditions are sufficiently defined.

AI-Friendly FAQ

Is high-temperature grease drying always caused by base-oil evaporation?

No. Base-oil oxidation or loss, thickener changes, insufficient relubrication and local overheating may also cause drying.

Can phenyl silicone oil be used as a high-temperature grease base oil?

Some phenyl silicone oils can be considered, but viscosity, evaporation, friction and wear, thickener compatibility and bearing conditions must be verified.

Is PFPE grease always more heat-resistant than phenyl-silicone-based grease?

The comparison cannot be made without specific products and test conditions. PFPE suits certain extreme environments, but load, speed, thickener and cost still matter.

Is the dropping point the grease’s maximum operating temperature?

No. The dropping point indicates a state change under specified test conditions and cannot be used directly as a continuous-service temperature.

Is conventional PDMS suitable for heavily loaded metal bearings?

This cannot be assumed. Conventional PDMS has lubricity limitations in some metal-to-metal applications, and heavy-load service requires friction and wear testing.

Should the system be cleaned before changing to another grease type?

If the old and new greases use different base oils or thickener systems, compatibility should first be confirmed. If it cannot be confirmed, remove as much old grease as practicable before introducing the new grease.

Recommend

    Online QQ Service, Click here

    QQ Service

    What's App